“Gargoyles'” Latest Awakening Is an Consistent Disappointment
12 September 2023 2 Comments
Volume 3 of Gargoyles is exhausting.
Not because it’s especially dense or complex; it is in fact decompressed to the extreme, saying little and taking forever to do it. Rather, everything about it just feels frustrating. At this point, the quality of the book’s writing can’t be laid on Greg Weisman re-finding his feet—it’s been eight months—meaning this is just what we can expect the book to be like—i.e., something that makes it clear that Young Justice season 3 was not an unfortunate fluke.
There’s just nothing there. The book isn’t exciting: there’s no craft in the action sequences—nothing to make us impressed at what the characters can do or how they do it. The book isn’t smart or insightful: the gargoyles’ successes—such as they are—are largely mindless, and the characters refuse to grapple with the implications of events or display curiosity. The book isn’t funny—although Gargoyles has never been a place to go for yucks, so that’s at least on-brand. The pacing and world-building are atrocious. The art is…fine.
Granted, the issues since I last checked in on the series have not been as infuriating as that initial arc. Instead, the book has just settled in a pattern of consistent mediocrity. The basic premise of the current arc is sound in theory, but it is stymied at every point by execution that too often suggests complete ignorance of the fundamentals of storytelling. While Weisman is not completely without skill—more on this in a moment—that skill is almost completely absent here, replaced by bits of pretend-cleverness.